Non-unimodal Artinian Gorenstein algebras in embedding dimension 4

About 16 years old · traced to

It remains open whether a standard graded Artinian Gorenstein algebra of embedding dimension 4 can have a non-unimodal Hilbert function; the analogous phenomenon is impossible in dimensions at most 3 and occurs in dimensions at least 5.

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open

No proof or counterexample has been found: the question remains open in four variables, although it is settled in lower and higher dimensions.

The problem asks whether a standard graded Artinian Gorenstein algebra of embedding dimension 44 can have a non-unimodal Hilbert function. The literature records unimodality in dimensions at most 33 and examples in every dimension at least 55, leaving dimension 44 unresolved.

Known results

  • Stanley (1978): the smallest known non-unimodal example is (1,13,12,13,1)(1,13,12,13,1), in codimension 1313.
  • The 2007 analysis proves unimodality in codimension 44 when h4≤33h_4\le 33; its remaining case is h4=34h_4=34.
  • The 2010 paper proves unimodality in codimension 44 if a minimal generator has degree less than 55, and also when h4≤34h_4\le 34.
  • The 2022 work reiterates that examples exist in every codimension r≥5r\ge 5, while codimension 44 remains open.

Current status (as of August 2026): Unimodality is established for several substantial codimension-44 subclasses, but the existence of a non-unimodal example in embedding dimension 44 remains open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.