← All problems

Takahashi’s question on direct summands of syzygies

Let (R,m,k)(R,\mathfrak m,\Bbbk) be a commutative noetherian local ring, and let ΩnR(k)\Omega_n^R(\Bbbk) denote the nnth syzygy of the residue field in a minimal free resolution of k\Bbbk, for some n≥0n\geq 0. If ΩnR(k)≅M⊕N\Omega_n^R(\Bbbk)\cong M\oplus N with M≠0M\neq 0 and G ⁣ ⁣-dim⁡RM<∞\operatorname{G\!\!-dim}_R M<\infty, must RR be Gorenstein?

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A November 2026 preprint claims to settle Takahashi’s question affirmatively, but the result has not yet received independent mathematical assessment.

Takahashi posed the question in 2007: whether a nonzero finite-Gorenstein-dimension direct summand in a syzygy of the residue field forces the local ring to be Gorenstein. The new preprint claims an affirmative answer via an Ext-vanishing criterion.

Known results

  • Takahashi (2007): affirmative for syzygy degrees n≤2n\leq 2, with strong structural conclusions.
  • Ghosh (2016): affirmative for Cohen–Macaulay local rings of minimal multiplicity.
  • Ghosh (2016): an Ext-vanishing criterion applies to maximal Cohen–Macaulay quotients of finite sums of syzygies.

November 2026 claimed resolution

Luigi Ferraro’s preprint On a question of Takahashi concerning direct summands of syzygies claims the general implication, using an Ext-vanishing theorem and a broader eventual-vanishing result. This is an unrefereed claim and remains unverified.

Current status (as of November 2026): The general question is claimed solved affirmatively by an unrefereed preprint, while the claimed proof remains unverified.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.