← All problems

Carpenter problem for subfactors

Given an inclusion N⊂MN\subset M of II1\mathrm{II}_1 factors and its trace-preserving conditional expectation EN:M→NE_N:M\to N, characterize those inclusions for which every positive contraction b∈Nb\in N, כלומר every bb satisfying 0≤b≤10\le b\le 1, is the conditional expectation of a projection in MM: ∀b∈N (0≤b≤1 ⟹ ∃p∈M (p=p∗=p2 ∧ EN(p)=b))\forall b\in N\,(0\le b\le 1\ \Longrightarrow\ \exists p\in M\,(p=p^*=p^2\ \land\ E_N(p)=b)).

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A new preprint settles the Carpenter property for a broad class of infinite-index subfactors, but the general problem remains open.

The Carpenter problem asks when every positive contraction in a smaller factor is the conditional expectation of a projection from a larger factor. The new result treats uniform infinite-index subfactors and includes a conjecture for ICC group inclusions.

November 2026 preprint

Dietmar Bisch and Julio Cáceres claim that every positive contraction has the required projection representation under their stated uniform infinite-index hypothesis, thereby settling the indicated ICC group-inclusion conjecture. The preprint is unrefereed, and no independent assessment was found.

Current status (as of November 2026): The Carpenter property is claimed for uniform infinite-index subfactors and the stated ICC group-inclusion conjecture, while the broader problem remains open and the claim is unverified.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.