← All problems

Banakh–Bardyla question on homomorphic images of complete semilattices

For every complete topologized semilattice X,X, every Hausdorff semitopological semilattice Y,Y, and every continuous homomorphism f:X→Y,f:X\to Y, the image f[X]f[X] is closed in Y.Y.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

An unrefereed 2026 preprint claims to settle the question affirmatively, but the claim has not been independently checked.

Banakh and Bardyla asked whether every continuous homomorphism from a complete semilattice into a Hausdorff semitopological semilattice has closed image. Their question was recorded in their 2018 work and published in 2020.

Known results

  • Sequential Hausdorff targets: closed images (Banakh–Bardyla, 2018).
  • Functionally Hausdorff targets: closed images (Banakh–Bardyla–Ravsky, 2018).
  • The same conclusion holds under the weaker separation condition T~2δ\widetilde T_{2\delta}.
  • The unrestricted Hausdorff semitopological case was explicitly left open in the 2022 survey.

2026 preprint claiming a solution

Osipov and Kazachenko’s preprint Idempotent Ultrafilters and Closed Images of Complete Semilattices claims the affirmative closed-image theorem in the general setting and derives closedness of the natural order. It is unrefereed, and no independent mathematical assessment was found.

Current status (as of November 2026): The general question has a claimed affirmative solution in an unrefereed preprint, while the earlier special cases are established and independent verification of the full claim is absent.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.