← All problems

Walther’s open problem on regularization of solution manifolds

Let h>0h>0, n∈Nn\in\mathbb{N}, U⊂C1([−h,0],Rn)U\subset C^1([-h,0],\mathbb{R}^n) be open, and let f:U→Rnf:U\to\mathbb{R}^n be continuously differentiable. Assume that for every ϕ∈U\phi\in U, the derivative Df(ϕ)Df(\phi) has a continuous linear extension Def(ϕ):C([−h,0],Rn)→RnD_ef(\phi):C([-h,0],\mathbb{R}^n)\to\mathbb{R}^n, with (ϕ,χ)↦Def(ϕ)χ(\phi,\chi)\mapsto D_ef(\phi)\chi jointly continuous. Define the solution manifold Xf={ϕ∈U:ϕ′(0)=f(ϕ)}X_f=\{\phi\in U:\phi'(0)=f(\phi)\} and the zero manifold X0={ϕ∈C1([−h,0],Rn):ϕ′(0)=0}X_0=\{\phi\in C^1([-h,0],\mathbb{R}^n):\phi'(0)=0\}. Does there exist a global C1C^1 diffeomorphism Φ\Phi from UU onto an open subset of C1([−h,0],Rn)C^1([-h,0],\mathbb{R}^n) such that Φ(Xf)\Phi(X_f) is an open subset of X0X_0? The sought regularization is additionally required, in the strengthened formulation reported by the source, to preserve the value at zero, to agree with the original history on [−h,−τ][-h,-\tau] for every prescribed τ∈(0,h)\tau\in(0,h), to be arbitrarily close to the identity in the supremum norm, and to be connected to the identity by a jointly C1C^1 family of diffeomorphisms.

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A new unrefereed preprint claims to solve the problem globally, but the claim has not been independently checked.

Walther’s problem asks for a global regularization of solution manifolds for state-dependent delay equations, rather than only local coordinate changes. The latest preprint claims a global straightening construction with the required properties.

Known results

  • Walther, 2026: local diffeomorphisms regularize suitable portions of XfX_f onto open subsets of X0X_0.
  • Earlier work, 2024: diffeomorphisms were obtained for restricted manifolds XF,bX_{F,b} under sufficient conditions.
  • Earlier work, 2021: a finite atlas of at most 2k2^k local or piecewise charts was constructed, not one global regularization.

November 2026 global straightening theorem

A preprint by Lily DiPaulo claims a global straightening theorem: the construction preserves histories away from the delay endpoint, can be arbitrarily close to the identity in supremum norm, and extends to some Hilbert-valued histories. If correct, this supplies the global regularization sought by Walther; the retrieved evidence identifies no independent assessment.

Current status (as of November 2026): A preprint claims the global problem is solved, while the earlier local results and the new global claim remain mathematically unverified in the retrieved evidence.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.