Farah’s 2004 Fσδ-ideal question
Is every ideal on a Farah ideal? Precisely, for every ideal that is an subset of —that is, a countable intersection of sets—do there exist hereditary closed sets , for , such that , where ?
References
- On Farah ideals and beyond — arXiv — Adam Kwela
Source: arXiv
Progress summary
A November 2026 preprint claims to disprove Farah’s conjecture and produce many counterexamples, but the result has not been independently assessed.
Farah asked in 2004 whether every ideal is a Farah ideal; this was recorded as Question 5.7(i) in a later survey. The latest preprint claims a negative answer.
Known results
Every analytic -ideal is a Farah ideal; the survey records this background result but does not give a resolution of Farah’s question.
November 2, 2026 claimed counterexample
Adam Kwela’s preprint On Farah ideals and beyond claims that not every ideal is Farah and constructs a continuum-sized antichain of non-Farah ideals. The claim is based on an unrefereed preprint and has no independent mathematical assessment in the retrieved sources.
Current status (as of November 2026): The question is claimed solved negatively, with a claimed continuum-sized family of counterexamples, but the preprint remains unverified.
Sources
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.