← All problems

Generalized egalitarianism characterization problem

Let L\mathcal{L} be the stated class of Lorenz curves and let ⪰\succeq be a binary relation on L\mathcal{L}. Do complete preorder, primal mixture independence, dual mixture independence, continuity, weak Lorenz dominance, and nontriviality imply that, for all L1,L2∈LL_1,L_2\in\mathcal{L}, L1⪰L2L_1\succeq L_2 if and only if ∫01L1(x) dx≥∫01L2(x) dx\displaystyle\int_0^1L_1(x)\,dx\geq\int_0^1L_2(x)\,dx? Equivalently, do these six axioms uniquely characterize ordering by the Lorenz-area functional A(L)=∫01L(x) dxA(L)=\displaystyle\int_0^1L(x)\,dx?

Equivalent formulations
  1. The same ordering is characterized by the opposite Gini-type normalization of Lorenz area: for the relevant normalization G(L)=1−2∫01L(x) dxG(L)=1-2\displaystyle\int_0^1L(x)\,dx, one has L1⪰L2L_1\succeq L_2 if and only if G(L1)≤G(L2)G(L_1)\leq G(L_2).

    source: A Proof for Generalized Egalitarianism

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

An October 2026 preprint claims to solve the characterization problem, but no independent verification has been found.

The problem asks whether six axioms uniquely force the Lorenz-area, equivalently Gini-type, ordering. Wei ShuAng’s October 2026 preprint claims that they do, for the stated class of Lorenz curves.

Known results

  • Aaberge’s one-sided integral-representation strategy was challenged by endpoint-singularity counterexamples reported in Measure of Morality (2025).
  • A prior repair reportedly imposed a stronger quantitative Archimedean regularity condition; the new preprint claims to remove it.

October 2026 claimed characterization

The preprint’s Theorem 1 claims that complete preorder, primal and dual mixture independence, continuity, weak Lorenz dominance, and nontriviality force ordering by A(L)=∫01L(x) dxA(L)=\int_{0}^{1}L(x)\,dx, equivalently by the opposite Gini normalization. The claim is unrefereed and has no retrieved independent mathematical assessment.

Current status (as of November 2026): The characterization is claimed solved by an unrefereed preprint, but remains mathematically unverified; no broader research-program resolution is established.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.