← All problems

Symmetry of global minimizers for the critical curl quotient

Let p=3/2p=3/2 and p∗=3p^*=3. For a vector potential uu on R3\mathbb{R}^3, define the gauge-invariant critical Sobolev-curl quotient by Q(u)=∥∇×u∥L3/2(R3)inf⁡ϕ∥u+∇ϕ∥L3(R3)\displaystyle \mathcal{Q}(u)=\frac{\|\nabla\times u\|_{L^{3/2}(\mathbb{R}^3)}}{\inf_{\phi}\|u+\nabla\phi\|_{L^3(\mathbb{R}^3)}}, where the infimum is over admissible scalar gauge functions ϕ\phi. Let S3/2,curlS_{3/2,\mathrm{curl}} be the infimum of Q\mathcal{Q} over nontrivial admissible fields, and let S3/2,curlTS_{3/2,\mathrm{curl}}^{\mathcal{T}} and S3/2,curlSS_{3/2,\mathrm{curl}}^{\mathcal{S}} denote the corresponding infima in the toroidal and poloidal symmetry classes. The critical curl extremal problem asks whether S3/2,curl=S3/2,curlT=S3/2,curlSS_{3/2,\mathrm{curl}}=S_{3/2,\mathrm{curl}}^{\mathcal{T}}=S_{3/2,\mathrm{curl}}^{\mathcal{S}}, and whether every unrestricted minimizer is, up to scaling, Euclidean symmetries, and admissible curl-free gauge terms, one of the classified toroidal or poloidal extremals.

Equivalent formulations
  1. Equivalently, the conjecture asks whether the sharp unrestricted critical curl constant satisfies S3/2,curl=S3/2,curlT=S3/2,curlS\displaystyle S_{3/2,\mathrm{curl}}=S_{3/2,\mathrm{curl}}^{\mathcal{T}}=S_{3/2,\mathrm{curl}}^{\mathcal{S}}, so that the toroidal and poloidal restricted extremals are also unrestricted minimizers.

    source: Mederski, Critical curl extremals and the hyperbolic plane

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A new paper settles important symmetry-restricted cases, but does not determine whether those solutions are the true global minimizers.

The problem asks whether global minimizers of the critical curl quotient have the conjectured symmetry, equivalently whether the restricted extremals are unrestricted minimizers. Frank and Loss posed the sharp-constant and optimizer questions; the available sources give no year.

October 30, 2026 restricted-extremal result

Jarosław Mederski reports, for R3\mathbb{R}^{3} at p=3/2p=3/2, that the toroidal and poloidal restricted constants coincide:

S3/2,curlT=S3/2,curlS=2π ΛH2.S_{3/2,\mathrm{curl}}^{\mathcal{T}}=S_{3/2,\mathrm{curl}}^{\mathcal{S}}=\sqrt{2\pi}\,\Lambda_{\mathbb{H}^{2}}.

The corresponding restricted extremals are classified up to the stated symmetries and curl-free gauge terms, with an improved upper bound of approximately 11.294811.2948 and a reported numerical value of approximately 11.261511.2615. The unrestricted sharp constant and global-minimizer classification remain open; the claim is not independently verified here.

Current status (as of November 2026): Restricted toroidal and poloidal cases are claimed to be classified, but the unrestricted sharp constant, global-minimizer question, and symmetry conjecture remain open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.