← All problems

Hibi–Li conjecture on order and chain polytopes

For every finite poset PP with n=∣P∣n=|P|, and for every integer kk with 0≤k≤n−10\le k\le n-1, the order polytope and chain polytope satisfy fk(O(P))≤fk(C(P))f_k(\mathcal{O}(P))\le f_k(\mathcal{C}(P)). Moreover, if equality holds for some kk with 1≤k≤n−11\le k\le n-1, then O(P)\mathcal{O}(P) and C(P)\mathcal{C}(P) are unimodularly equivalent.

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A 2026 preprint claims to settle the conjecture, with a later report correcting the equality claim in the one-dimensional case; the claim has not been independently checked.

The Hibi–Li conjecture asserts that, for every finite poset, the chain polytope has at least as many kk-faces as the order polytope. Hibi and Li proposed it in 2016, together with an equality characterization.

Known results

  • Hibi and Li, 2016: proved the facet inequality and characterized equality by unimodular equivalence.
  • Hibi, Li, Sahara, and Shikama: proved that the two polytopes always have the same number of edges.
  • Special cases were established for maximal ranked posets and for arbitrary posets in dimension 22.
  • A 2021 survey recorded the general face inequalities as conjectural and summarized the known equality cases.

September–October 2026 claimed resolution and correction

Ghislain Fourier’s September 20, 2026 preprint claims the inequality fk(O(P))≤fk(C(P))f_k(\mathcal{O}(P))\le f_k(\mathcal{C}(P)) for every finite poset and every 0≤k≤n−10\le k\le n-1. A later October 28, 2026 report says the equality characterization holds for 2≤k≤n−12\le k\le n-1, but fails for k=1k=1, with the five-element obstruction XX providing the counterexample. These resolution claims remain unverified.

Current status (as of November 2026): The all-dimensional inequality and the corrected equality characterization are claimed in 2026 preprints, but neither claim has independent mathematical verification in the retrieved record.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.