Van der Waerden-type conjecture for Galois groups of cubic surfaces
Let denote the number of smooth homogeneous cubic forms with all coefficients of absolute value at most such that, for the cubic surface defined by , the Galois image acting on the lines satisfies . The van der Waerden-type problem asks whether, for every , one has as .
Equivalent formulations
With defined as above, O'Dorney conjectures that as .
References
- Van der Waerden's Problem for Cubic Surfaces — arXiv — Evan O'Dorney
Source: arXiv
Progress summary
A new paper substantially improves the counting estimates for exceptional cubic surfaces, but the main conjectured bound remains open because of one unresolved discriminant obstruction.
The conjecture predicts a van der Waerden-type exceptional-set bound of for Galois groups arising from cubic surfaces. The central unresolved issue is controlling surfaces whose Galois group lies in the index-two subgroup of .
Known results
- Elsenhans and Jahnel construct cubic surfaces with Galois group equal to the index-two subgroup of , of order .
- For their surfaces, membership in that subgroup is equivalent to being a square in .
- They derive square-divisibility constraints on the normalized parameters, including even -adic valuations for primes .
October 2026 improved estimates
Evan O'Dorney's paper claims sharper bounds for five maximal-subgroup classes and identifies the index-two subgroup as the principal obstruction to the expected estimate. The paper also proposes, but does not prove, asymptotics for the exceptional count.
Current status (as of October 2026): The general conjectured bound remains open; claimed progress covers five subgroup classes, while the index-two discriminant case is unresolved.
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.