← All problems

Universality of hierarchical laminates for planar two-phase composites

For every pair of constituent material laws C1,C2C_1,C_2 governing a planar two-phase linear system and every nontrivial phase fraction θ∈(0,1)\theta\in(0,1), let Eθ(C1,C2)\mathcal{E}_\theta(C_1,C_2) be the set of effective properties generated by periodic two-phase microstructures with phase fraction θ\theta, and let Hθ(C1,C2)\mathcal{H}_\theta(C_1,C_2) be the subset generated by finite hierarchical laminates. The universality conjecture asserts that Eθ(C1,C2)‾=Hθ(C1,C2)‾\overline{\mathcal{E}_\theta(C_1,C_2)}=\overline{\mathcal{H}_\theta(C_1,C_2)} for all such constituents and phase fractions.

Equivalent formulations
  1. In the associated two-well relaxation formulation, for the relevant pair of positive-definite quadratic forms Q1,Q2Q_1,Q_2, the quasiconvex and rank-one-convex envelopes are equal: Qqc=QrcQ_\mathrm{qc}=Q_\mathrm{rc} for f=min⁡{Q1,Q2}f=\min\{Q_1,Q_2\}.

    source: Hierarchical Laminates Cannot Reproduce All Effective Properties of Planar Two-Phase Composites: A Counterexample with a 16-Component Potential

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A recent preprint claims a counterexample showing that hierarchical laminates cannot realize every planar two-phase composite, but the claim has not been independently assessed.

The problem asks whether hierarchical laminates are universal for planar two-phase composites, equivalently whether the relevant rank-one-convex and quasiconvex closures coincide. No proposer or date is identified in the retrieved sources.

Known results

  • The n=1n=1 case was established under additional commutation or definite-sign assumptions by Nesi and Grabovsky, building on Lurie–Cherkaev and Murat–Tartar.
  • The unrestricted n=1n=1 case remains open in the cited survey.
  • Equality of the two closures for n=2n=2 is explicitly listed as open.
  • Planar elasticity evidence points toward equality in some fixed-orientation settings, without proving it.

Recent counterexample preprint (date not stated)

Lianghao Cao claims to construct periodic microstructures outside the closure of hierarchical-laminate responses, yielding a strict separation between the quasiconvex and rank-one-convex envelopes. If correct, this refutes broad universality; the retrieved record provides no independent mathematical assessment.

Current status (as of October 2026): A negative answer is claimed by Cao's preprint, but it remains unverified; the underlying universality question is not independently settled.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.