← All problems

Mason's conjecture, uniform tensor-product formulation

For all positive integers r,s,r′,s′r,s,r',s', the generic tensor product Ur,r+s⊗genUr′,r′+s′U_{r,r+s}\otimes_{\mathrm{gen}}U_{r',r'+s'} is the freest, equivalently maximal under the freer-than order, among matroid tensor products of the uniform matroids Ur,r+sU_{r,r+s} and Ur′,r′+s′U_{r',r'+s'}; that is, there is no matroid tensor product TT of these factors such that Ur,r+s⊗genUr′,r′+s′U_{r,r+s}\otimes_{\mathrm{gen}}U_{r',r'+s'} is strictly freer than TT.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

An unrefereed preprint claims counterexamples that disprove the conjecture, while earlier work had established only restricted cases.

Mason's conjecture asserts that the generic tensor product of two uniform matroids is the freest matroid tensor product. The newly reported examples claim that this extremal description fails, and also challenge a related rigidity conjecture.

Known results

  • The conjecture is proved when a=1a=1 or m−a≤3m-a\leq 3, with the other parameters arbitrary.
  • The generic tensor-product statement is proved within the class of linearly representable matroids.
  • The analogous ordinary rigidity conjecture is false in ambient dimension at least 44, while the corresponding bipartite case had no known counterexample.

October 2026 counterexamples

Mykhaylo Tyomkyn's preprint claims that generic tensor products of two copies of U7,9U_{7,9}, and more generally of U7,a+7U_{7,a+7} and U7,b+7U_{7,b+7}, are not maximal. If correct, this disproves Mason's uniform tensor-product formulation and supplies related counterexamples to the Jackson--Tanigawa conjecture; the claim is unverified.

Current status (as of October 2026): The conjecture is claimed false by explicit generic tensor-product counterexamples, but the unrefereed claim has not been independently verified.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.