← All problems

Ascending chain condition for radical well-mixed difference ideals

For every difference field (K,σ)(K,\sigma), every finite tuple of difference indeterminates y\mathbf{y}, and every ascending chain I1⊆I2⊆⋯I_1\subseteq I_2\subseteq\cdots of radical well-mixed difference ideals of the difference polynomial ring K{y}K\{\mathbf{y}\}, there exists NN such that Im=INI_m=I_N for all m≥Nm\geq N. Here a difference ideal satisfies σ(I)⊆I\sigma(I)\subseteq I, is radical if fr∈If^r\in I for some r≥1r\geq 1 implies f∈If\in I, and is well-mixed if ab∈Iab\in I implies aσ(b)∈Ia\sigma(b)\in I.

Equivalent formulations
  1. For every difference field (K,σ)(K,\sigma), every finite tuple of difference indeterminates y\mathbf{y}, and every radical well-mixed difference ideal I⊆K{y}I\subseteq K\{\mathbf{y}\}, there exists a finite subset F⊆IF\subseteq I such that II is the radical well-mixed difference ideal generated by FF.

    source: The ascending chain condition for radical well-mixed difference ideals

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A new unrefereed preprint claims the finiteness problem is solved in all cases, but the claim has not been independently checked.

The problem asks whether every ascending chain of radical well-mixed difference ideals eventually stops. The general conjecture is attributed to Hrushovski; the latest preprint claims a full solution without the inversiveness assumption.

Known results

  • For binomial difference ideals, finite generation of radical well-mixed closures and the corresponding ascending chain condition were proved by Jie Wang in 2016; the arbitrary-binomial closure question remained open.

October 2026 claimed solution

Wei Li and Jie Wang claim that a contraction theorem from the inversive closure removes the inversiveness assumption and yields finite generation of the relevant closures, hence the full ascending chain condition. This is an unrefereed preprint claim; no independent assessment was found. A separate 2026 result for mixed difference ideals does not address radical well-mixed ideals.

Current status (as of October 2026): The full assertion is claimed in an unrefereed preprint but remains unverified; the binomial case is established, and no verified resolution or counterexample for radical well-mixed ideals is recorded.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.