← All problems

D-optimal design existence for orders 198 and 170

Determine whether D-optimal designs exist at orders 198198 and 170170. The corresponding supplementary-difference-set existence assertions are: there are subsets X,Y⊆Z99X,Y\subseteq\mathbb{Z}_{99} with ∣X∣=43|X|=43, ∣Y∣=42|Y|=42, such that every nonzero element of Z99\mathbb{Z}_{99} occurs exactly 3636 times among the ordered differences x−x′x-x' with x,x′∈Xx,x'\in X or with x,x′∈Yx,x'\in Y; and there are subsets X,Y⊆Z85X,Y\subseteq\mathbb{Z}_{85} with ∣X∣=39|X|=39, ∣Y∣=34|Y|=34, such that every nonzero element of Z85\mathbb{Z}_{85} occurs exactly 3131 times among the corresponding ordered differences. These supplementary difference sets yield D-optimal matrices of orders 2⋅99=1982\cdot99=198 and 2⋅85=1702\cdot85=170, respectively.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A specialist paper claims to settle both previously unresolved design orders, but the construction has not yet received independent mathematical verification.

The problem asks whether D-optimal designs exist at orders 198198 and 170170. Georgiou and Stylianou claim constructions via supplementary difference sets with parameters (99;43,42;36)(99;43,42;36) and (85;39,34;31)(85;39,34;31), respectively.

Known results

  • The two parameter sets were identified as unresolved exceptional cases among normalized D-optimal parameters with v<100v<100 (2022).
  • The smallest undecided case was reported as (85;39,34;31)(85;39,34;31) (2022).
  • Earlier constructions reached orders 118118, 138138, 150150, 154154, and 174174; order 198198 was then the smallest undecided order (2014/2015).

October 2026 construction claim

Georgiou and Stylianou report an exact compression-and-lifting search producing the two stated supplementary difference sets, hence a D-optimal matrix of order 198198 and new constructions at order 170170. The claim is supported here only by the specialist preprint; no independent assessment or verification was found.

Current status (as of October 2026): Existence at orders 198198 and 170170 is claimed in a specialist preprint but remains unverified in the available evidence.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.