← All problems

Bergelson's multiplicative recurrence question

Let S={2m3n:m,n≥1}S=\{2^m3^n:m,n\ge 1\}. Is SS a set of recurrence; that is, for every invertible measure-preserving transformation TT of a probability space (X,B,μ)(X,\mathcal B,\mu) and every measurable set A∈BA\in\mathcal B with μ(A)>0\mu(A)>0, does there exist r∈Sr\in S such that μ(A∩T−rA)>0\mu(A\cap T^{-r}A)>0? More generally, the same question may be asked for finitely generated multiplicative semigroups SPS_{\mathcal P} generated by a finite nonempty set of primes P\mathcal P.

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

An unrefereed October 2026 paper claims a negative answer to Bergelson’s recurrence question for many multiplicative time sets.

Bergelson posed the question in 1996, asking about recurrence along multiplicative times. It concerns whether the expected recurrence persists for broad finitely generated semigroups such as {2m3n}\{2^m3^n\}.

October 2026 negative-answer claim

Zhuowei Liu’s paper claims non-recurrence for semigroups including {2m3n}\{2^m3^n\} and gives a broader divisibility-based criterion. If correct, this answers Bergelson’s question negatively, but the paper is unrefereed and the claim has not been independently assessed.

Current status (as of October 2026): A paper claims to settle the question negatively for a broad class of multiplicative semigroups, but the result remains unverified.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.