← All problems

Choe et al. composition-operator compactness conjecture

For analytic self-maps φ,ψ:D→D\varphi,\psi:\mathbb{D}\to\mathbb{D} and exponents 0<p,q<∞0<p,q<\infty, the operator Cφ−CψC_{\varphi}-C_{\psi} is compact on Hp(D)H^p(\mathbb{D}) if and only if it is compact on Hq(D)H^q(\mathbb{D}), where Cφf=f∘φC_{\varphi}f=f\circ\varphi.

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A 2024 paper proves the original disk version, while a 2026 paper extends the phenomenon to a broader class of Hardy spaces on rooted trees.

The conjecture asks whether compactness of differences of composition operators on Hardy spaces is independent of the exponent. Choe and coauthors formulated it after earlier work by Shapiro and Sundberg.

Known results

  • The case p=2p=2 was established first, followed by a more explicit solution.
  • Independence of compactness from pp was known for 1≤p<∞1\le p<\infty.
  • A version dated October 13, 2024, proves independence for every 0<p<∞0<p<\infty and for arbitrary finite linear combinations ∑j=1NλjCφj\sum_{j=1}^{N}\lambda_j C_{\varphi_j}; in particular, it proves the Choe et al. conjecture for Cφ−CψC_\varphi-C_\psi on Hp(D)H^p(\mathbb{D}).

October 2026 rooted-tree extension

Lei Liu and Wanxin Ma report a structural characterization of compactness for finite linear combinations satisfying the CNC on Hardy spaces of homogeneous rooted trees, including difference-cancellation examples. This is a broader result in that setting, but its claim has not been independently verified here.

Current status (as of October 2026): The disk conjecture is claimed proved for all 0<p<∞0<p<\infty, and a separate rooted-tree extension is claimed; both remain unverified in this report, while analogous statements for arbitrary Hardy spaces remain open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.