← All problems

Perles–Shephard question on polytopes with facets Δ^p×Δ^q

Determine, for each dimension dd and simplex dimensions a,b≥1a,b\ge 1 satisfying a+b=d−1a+b=d-1, which dd-dimensional convex polytopes PP have every facet FF combinatorially isomorphic to the product Δa×Δb\Delta^a\times\Delta^b; in particular, determine for which dd such polytopes exist and classify them.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A new unverified preprint claims a sharp partial answer: these polytopes exist in four dimensions but not in five or more, while the general question remains open.

The Perles–Shephard question asks which polytopes can have every facet shaped as a product of two simplices. The latest work treats only the case of simplicial-prism facets, not every pair of simplex dimensions.

October 2026 simplicial-prism result

Federico Castillo, Guillermo Piñeda-Villavicencio, and José Alejandro Samper claim that polytopes with facets combinatorially equivalent to Δd−2×Δ1\Delta^{d-2}\times\Delta^1 do not exist for d≥5d\ge 5, while constructing infinite families in dimension 44. This is a claimed, unverified advance rather than a resolution of the full Perles–Shephard question.

Current status (as of October 2026): The simplicial-prism specialization is claimed to be settled for d≥5d\ge 5, with infinite four-dimensional families, but the full question for arbitrary Δp×Δq\Delta^p\times\Delta^q facets remains open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.