← All problems

Heisenberg-group Fuglede/isoperimetric conjecture for the Pansu sphere

Let H1\mathbb{H}^{1} be the sub-Riemannian Heisenberg group, let ∣E∣|E| denote Haar volume, and let PH(E)P_{\mathbb{H}}(E) denote the horizontal perimeter of a measurable set EE. Let BPB_{P} be the region enclosed by a rotationally symmetric Pansu sphere. Prove that, for every measurable set E⊂H1E\subset\mathbb{H}^{1} with 0<∣E∣<∞0<|E|<\infty, PH(E)≥PH(BP)(∣E∣∣BP∣)3/4P_{\mathbb{H}}(E)\geq P_{\mathbb{H}}(B_{P})\left(\frac{|E|}{|B_{P}|}\right)^{3/4}. Moreover, equality should hold only when EE, up to a null set, is a left translate and a Heisenberg dilation of BPB_{P}; equivalently, the Pansu sphere should be the isoperimetric boundary up to left translations and dilations.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A new paper proves local stability of the proposed shape, but the full isoperimetric conjecture remains unresolved.

Pansu conjectured in 19831983 that, up to left translation and dilation, the isoperimetric set in the Heisenberg group is the rotationally symmetric Pansu sphere. The unrestricted statement is known in H1\mathbb{H}^{1} only under additional regularity or convexity assumptions.

Known results

  • H1\mathbb{H}^{1}: the conjecture was proved under C2C^{2} regularity or convexity assumptions on minimizers (survey cited in 20152015).
  • Axially symmetric or suitably cylindrical competitors: established in Hn\mathbb{H}^{n} under those structural assumptions.
  • Constrained cylinder comparison: a calibration argument proves optimality for sets lying between a horizontal disk and its vertical cylinder.

October 2026 local stability

Davide Massenz, Roberto Monti, and Julián Pozuelo prove quantitative local Fuglede stability for suitable normal perturbations of the Pansu sphere in H1\mathbb{H}^{1}. This strengthens stability evidence but does not establish global optimality or classify all minimizers.

Current status (as of October 2026): Local quantitative stability is established in a restricted H1\mathbb{H}^{1} setting, while the unrestricted Pansu-sphere isoperimetric conjecture remains open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.