Wright’s Problem 16 cap-sufficiency proposal
Let be a bounded convex domain, let denote unnormalised arclength measure on , and define the lacunary maximal operator . For and , let and . For each fixed with , does the cap condition imply that is bounded on ?
References
- Lacunary maximal operators on convex boundaries — arXiv — Xi Cen, Xinfeng Wu
Source: arXiv
Progress summary
A new paper claims the proposed geometric test fails in several exponent ranges, but the full question is not settled.
Wright’s Problem 16 asks whether a natural cap-size integral condition is sufficient for boundedness of a lacunary maximal operator in the plane when the exponent differs from .
Known results
- For exponent , the cap condition characterizes boundedness on (classical result recorded in the problem sources).
- For , the analogous cap condition is necessary, but its sufficiency was posed as Problem 16.
- For flat-point examples, the condition holds exactly when ; the threshold is therefore .
October 2026 counterexample claim
Xi Cen and Xinfeng Wu claim that, for every fixed or , there is a smooth strictly convex domain satisfying the cap condition but failing restricted weak type. Their work also proposes a replacement sufficient condition for strong boundedness. The claim has not been independently verified in the retrieved material and does not address all exponents.
Current status (as of October 2026): The cap criterion is settled for and is necessary for ; its sufficiency is claimed to fail in the stated ranges, but that claim is unverified and the remaining exponent ranges are open.
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.