← All problems

T1 (general topology)

In topology and related branches of mathematics, a T1{}_{1} space is a topological space in which, for every pair of distinct points, each has a neighborhood not containing the other point. An R0{}_{0} space is one in which this holds for every pair of topologically distinguishable points. The properties T1T_{1} and R0R_{0} are examples of separation axioms.

Definitions

Let X be a topological space and let x and y be points in X. We say that x and y are separated if each lies in a neighbourhood that does not contain the other point.

  • X is called a T1{}_{1} space if any two distinct points in X are separated.
  • X is called an R0{}_{0} space if any two topologically distinguishable points in X are separated.

A T1T_{1} space is also called an accessible space or a space with Fréchet topology and an R0R_{0} space is also called a symmetric space. (The term Fréchet space also has an entirely different meaning in functional analysis. For this reason, the term T1T_{1} space is preferred. There is also a notion of a Fréchet–Urysohn space as a type of sequential space. The term symmetric space also has another meaning.)

A topological space is a T1T_{1} space if and only if it is both an R0R_{0} space and a Kolmogorov (or T0T_{0}) space (i.e., a space in which distinct points are topologically distinguishable). A topological space is an R0R_{0} space if and only if its Kolmogorov quotient is a T1T_{1} space.

Properties

If XX is a topological space then the following conditions are equivalent:

  1. XX is a T1T_{1} space.
  2. XX is a T0T_{0} space and an R0R_{0} space.
  3. Points are closed in XX; that is, for every point x∈X,x\in X, the singleton set {x}\{x\} is a closed subset of X.X.
  4. Every subset of XX is the intersection of all the open sets containing it.
  5. Every finite set is closed.
  6. Every cofinite set of XX is open.
  7. For every x∈X,x\in X, the fixed ultrafilter at xx converges only to x.x.
  8. For every subset SS of XX and every point x∈X,x\in X, xx is a limit point of SS if and only if every open neighbourhood of xx contains infinitely many points of S.S.
  9. Each map from the Sierpiński space to XX is trivial.
  10. The map from the Sierpiński space to the single point has the lifting property with respect to the map from XX to the single point.

If XX is a topological space then the following conditions are equivalent: (where cl⁡{x}\operatorname {cl} \{x\} denotes the closure of {x}\{x\})

  1. XX is an R0R_{0} space.
  2. Given any x∈X,x\in X, the closure of {x}\{x\} contains only the points that are topologically indistinguishable from x.x.
  3. The Kolmogorov quotient of XX is T1T_{1}.
  4. For any x,y∈X,x,y\in X, xx is in the closure of {y}\{y\} if and only if yy is in the closure of {x}.\{x\}.
  5. The specialization preorder on XX is symmetric (and therefore an equivalence relation).
  6. The sets cl⁡{x}\operatorname {cl} \{x\} for x∈Xx\in X form a partition of XX (that is, any two such sets are either identical or disjoint).
  7. If FF is a closed set and xx is a point not in FF, then F∩cl⁡{x}=∅.F\cap \operatorname {cl} \{x\}=\emptyset.
  8. Every neighbourhood of a point x∈Xx\in X contains cl⁡{x}.\operatorname {cl} \{x\}.
  9. Every open set is a union of closed sets.
  10. For every x∈X,x\in X, the fixed ultrafilter at xx converges only to the points that are topologically indistinguishable from x.x.

In any topological space we have, as properties of any two points, the following implications

separated  ⟹  topologically distinguishable  ⟹  distinct.{\text{separated}}\implies {\text{topologically distinguishable}}\implies {\text{distinct.}}

If the first arrow can be reversed the space is R0R_{0}. If the second arrow can be reversed the space is T0T_{0}. If the composite arrow can be reversed the space is T1T_{1}. A space is T1T_{1} if and only if it is both R0R_{0} and T0T_{0}.

A finite T1T_{1} space is necessarily discrete (since every set is closed).

Examples

  • Sierpiński space is a simple example of a topology that is T0T_{0} but is not T1T_{1}, and hence also not R0R_{0}.

  • The overlapping interval topology is a simple example of a topology that is T0T_{0} but is not T1T_{1}.

  • Every weakly Hausdorff space is T1T_{1} but the converse is not true in general.

  • The cofinite topology on an infinite set is a simple example of a topology that is T1T_{1} but is not Hausdorff (T2T_{2}). This follows since no two nonempty open sets of the cofinite topology are disjoint. Specifically, let XX be the set of integers, and define the open sets OAO_{A} to be those subsets of XX that contain all but a finite subset AA of X.X. Then given distinct integers xx and yy:

  • the open set O{x}O_{\{x\}} contains yy but not x,x, and the open set O{y}O_{\{y\}} contains xx and not yy;

  • equivalently, every singleton set {x}\{x\} is the complement of the open set O{x},O_{\{x\}}, so it is a closed set;

so the resulting space is T1T_{1} by each of the definitions above. This space is not T2T_{2}, because the intersection of any two open sets OAO_{A} and OBO_{B} is OA∩OB=OA∪B,O_{A}\cap O_{B}=O_{A\cup B}, which is never empty. Alternatively, the set of even integers is compact but not closed, which would be impossible in a Hausdorff space.

  • The above example can be modified slightly to create the double-pointed cofinite topology, which is an example of an R0R_{0} space that is neither T1T_{1} nor R1R_{1}. Let XX be the set of integers again, and using the definition of OAO_{A} from the previous example, define a subbase of open sets GxG_{x} for any integer xx to be Gx=O{x,x+1}G_{x}=O_{\{x,x+1\}} if xx is an even number, and Gx=O{x−1,x}G_{x}=O_{\{x-1,x\}} if xx is odd. Then the basis of the topology are given by finite intersections of the subbasic sets: given a finite set A,A,the open sets of XX are
UA:=⋂x∈AGx.U_{A}:=\bigcap _{x\in A}G_{x}.

The resulting space is not T0T_{0} (and hence not T1T_{1}), because the points xx and x+1x+1 (for xx even) are topologically indistinguishable; but otherwise it is essentially equivalent to the previous example.

References
  1. Wikipedia, Glossary of general topology, the glossary this definition comes from.

Source: Wikipedia