← All problems

Nonvanishing of 2-primary Kolyvagin classes

Let E/QE/\mathbf{Q} be an elliptic curve and let K=Q(D)K=\mathbf{Q}(\sqrt{D}), with D<−4D<-4, satisfy the Heegner hypothesis for EE. For an optimal 22-indivisible modular parametrization φ0\varphi_0 of EE, does there always exist a finite set of primes TT, with nT=∏q∈Tqn_T=\prod_{q\in T}q, such that the standard mod-22 Kolyvagin class κnT,1std(φ0)\kappa^{\mathrm{std}}_{n_T,1}(\varphi_0) is nonzero, without imposing additional surjectivity or cohomological exclusion hypotheses?

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A 2026 paper gives only conditional progress, so the unrestricted existence claim remains open.

The problem asks whether every eligible elliptic-curve and imaginary-quadratic-field pair admits a finite support producing a nonzero mod-22 Kolyvagin class without auxiliary hypotheses. Zhiqi Sun’s October 2026 paper formulates the broader nonvanishing conjecture but does not prove this unconditional case.

October 22, 2026 conditional advance

Sun assumes surjectivity modulo 2L2^L and a level-44 cohomological exclusion condition. Under these assumptions, the paper constructs a terminal support TT and proves, for a 22-indivisible parametrization, that κnT,1std(φ0)≠0\kappa^{\mathrm{std}}_{n_T,1}(\varphi_0)\neq 0 is equivalent to i(E,K)=0\mathfrak{i}(E,K)=0. This is substantive conditional progress, but the claim is unverified and does not establish the unrestricted statement.

Current status (as of November 2026): conditional nonvanishing has been claimed under additional hypotheses, while unrestricted nonvanishing remains open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.