← All problems

Brasco–De Philippis quadratic stability open problem for the Ashbaugh–Benguria inequality

Let n≥2n\ge 2, let Ω⊂Rn\Omega\subset\mathbb{R}^n be a bounded convex domain, and let λ1(Ω)<λ2(Ω)≤⋯\lambda_1(\Omega)<\lambda_2(\Omega)\le\cdots denote the Dirichlet Laplace eigenvalues. Define the Ashbaugh–Benguria deficit by δAB(Ω):=jn/2,12jn/2−1,12−λ2(Ω)λ1(Ω)\delta_{\mathrm{AB}}(\Omega):=\dfrac{j_{n/2,1}^2}{j_{n/2-1,1}^2}-\dfrac{\lambda_2(\Omega)}{\lambda_1(\Omega)}, and the Fraenkel asymmetry by A(Ω):=inf⁡x∈Rn∣Ω△(x+BΩ)∣∣Ω∣\mathcal{A}(\Omega):=\inf_{x\in\mathbb{R}^n}\dfrac{|\Omega\mathbin{\triangle}(x+B_\Omega)|}{|\Omega|}, where BΩB_\Omega is a ball with ∣BΩ∣=∣Ω∣|B_\Omega|=|\Omega|. The conjecture asks whether there exists a constant cn>0c_n>0 such that δAB(Ω)≥cnA(Ω)2\delta_{\mathrm{AB}}(\Omega)\ge c_n\mathcal{A}(\Omega)^2 for every such Ω\Omega. Equivalently, the deficit in the Ashbaugh–Benguria eigenvalue-ratio inequality should control the square of the Fraenkel asymmetry.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A 2026 preprint claims to refute the proposed quadratic stability law and identify the sharp replacement exponents, but this has not been independently verified.

The problem asks whether the Ashbaugh–Benguria eigenvalue-ratio inequality admits the quadratic stability estimate proposed by Brasco and De Philippis. The underlying inequality was proved by Ashbaugh and Benguria in 1991.

Known results

A quantitative estimate is obtained from quantitative Faber–Krahn inequalities on the two nodal domains and a two-ball Fraenkel-asymmetry estimate, but an earlier source explicitly left sharpness unresolved.

October 2026 claimed refutation

Long-Han Huang, Yuxuan Zhou, and Wenming Zou’s preprint claims sharp stability exponents for Fraenkel asymmetry and Hausdorff distance and explicitly refutes the quadratic estimate in Open Problem 7.657.65. If correct, this settles the tracked question by replacing the conjectured exponent with sharp alternatives.

Current status (as of October 2026): The quadratic estimate is claimed refuted by an unrefereed preprint, but the result remains unverified and the general problem is not independently settled.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.