← All problems

Kielak–Kropholler–Wilkes conjecture on ℓ²-Betti numbers

For every fixed pair of integers n≥2n\ge 2 and m≥1m\ge 1, let Gn,m,ℓG_{n,m,\ell} be a random group in the few-relator model with nn generators and mm relators, where the relator length ℓ\ell tends to infinity. Then, with probability tending to 11, β1(2)(Gn,m,ℓ)=max⁡{n−m−1,0}\beta^{(2)}_1(G_{n,m,\ell})=\max\{n-m-1,0\}. In particular, β1(2)(Gn,m,ℓ)=0\beta^{(2)}_1(G_{n,m,\ell})=0 asymptotically almost surely when m≥n−1m\ge n-1.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A new paper claims the conjectured formula for random groups with few relators, but the broader problem remains open and the claim has not been independently corroborated.

Kielak, Kropholler, and Wilkes formulated the conjecture in 2020 for random groups: the first ℓ2\ell^2-Betti number should equal max⁡(n−m−1,0)\max(n-m-1,0) with high probability, alongside predictions about coherence and incoherence.

Known results

  • For n≥3n\geq 3 and deficiency d>1d>1, b1(2)(G)=d−1b^{(2)}_1(G)=d-1 and bi(2)(G)=0b^{(2)}_i(G)=0 for i≠1i\ne 1 with probability tending to 11 (Kielak, Kropholler, Wilkes, 2020).
  • In that regime, random groups are coherent and embed in virtually free-by-cyclic groups with probability tending to 11 (Kielak, Kropholler, Wilkes, 2020).
  • For deficiency 11, free-by-cyclic behavior was proved with positive asymptotic probability (Kielak, Kropholler, Wilkes, 2020).
  • For two generators and at least two relators, vanishing of b1(2)b^{(2)}_1 and incoherence hold with high probability (Kielak, Kropholler, Wilkes, 2020).

October 2026 few-relator claim

Donoso-Echenique and Silva claim that the formula is proved throughout the few-relator model, including vanishing when m≥n−1m\geq n-1. This would settle the conjectured random-group statement in that model, but the retrieved arXiv search did not independently corroborate the claim; it does not address arbitrary finitely presented groups.

Current status (as of October 2026): Established partial cases remain available, while the new few-relator result is an unverified claim and the broader arbitrary-group problem remains open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.