Closedness of bounded strength and partition-rank loci
Let be an algebraically closed field. For integers , , and a finite-dimensional -vector space , define the strength locus by . For integers and , and finite-dimensional vector spaces , define the partition-rank locus to consist of tensors expressible as a sum of at most tensors, each of which factors across some nontrivial bipartition of . Determine, for all and all , whether and are Zariski closed in their respective ambient spaces. In particular, determine whether there exists a quartic form of strength exactly in the Zariski closure of the locus of quartics of strength at most , and determine the corresponding closedness behavior for partition rank.
References
- Closedness of bounded strength and partition rank loci — arXiv — Benjamin Baily, Alessandro Danelon
Source: arXiv
Progress summary
An unrefereed preprint claims a new counterexample and a broad classification, but no independent verification has appeared.
The problem asks when bounded-strength and partition-rank loci are Zariski closed. The central new claim concerns a quartic of strength lying in the closure of the strength- locus, with suspension arguments extending the failure pattern.
Known results
- Bounded strength is closed for cubics; arbitrary-degree closedness was previously open (Ballico, Bik, Oneto, and Ventura, 2018).
- For quartics in sufficiently many variables, the strength- locus is not closed (2021); the minimal threshold and variable count were left open.
- A survey records that strength is not Zariski closed and that partition-rank loci were already believed nonclosed for tensors of order .
October 2026 claimed classification
Benjamin Baily and Alessandro Danelon claim that a quartic of strength lies in the closure of strength at most , and that suspension classifies closedness failures across all rank bounds. The result is reported only in an unrefereed preprint and remains unverified.
Current status (as of October 2026): Earlier nonclosedness results are established, while the claimed strength- closure example and all-threshold classification remain unverified.
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.