← All problems

Cuntz–Mücksch 37-line bound conjecture

Every sporadic simplicial arrangement A\mathcal{A} of real projective lines in RP2\mathbb{RP}^2 has at most 3737 lines; that is, ∣A∣≤37|\mathcal{A}|\le 37.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

An unrefereed preprint claims to disprove the proposed limit by exhibiting a new arrangement with more lines, but the claim has not been independently confirmed.

The conjecture, proposed by Cuntz and Geis, asserts that every sporadic simplicial line arrangement in the real projective plane has at most 3737 lines. It is part of the program classifying sporadic arrangements beyond the known infinite families.

Known results

  • A 20112011 computation classified simplicial arrangements through 2727 lines and found missing examples with 2222, 2323, 2424, and 2525 lines.
  • A 20212021 paper recorded the 3737-line conjecture and classified nearly free simplicial arrangements with at most 2727 lines.
  • A 20242024 paper proved only a conditional asymptotic classification, assuming at most KnKn double points for sufficiently large nn; it did not establish the universal bound.

October 2026 claimed counterexample

On October 20, 2026, Tomás S. R. Silva’s preprint reported a 5151-line sporadic simplicial arrangement outside the known infinite families, with exact incidence data and a finite verifier. If correct, it disproves the 3737-line bound; the preprint is unrefereed and the verifier is not independent mathematical confirmation.

Current status (as of October 2026): The 3737-line conjecture is claimed false by an unverified 5151-line counterexample; absent confirmation, the counterexample and the resulting refutation remain unsettled.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.