← All problems

Hrušák–Meza-Alcántara Farah-ideal question

For every ideal I\mathcal{I} on N\mathbb{N}, I\mathcal{I} is Farah if and only if I\mathcal{I} is weakly Farah; equivalently, the class of Farah ideals coincides with the class of weakly Farah ideals.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A new unrefereed paper claims to settle the main structural question, but the result has not been independently checked.

The Hrušák–Meza-Alcántara question asks whether the relevant classes of ideals coincide. Earlier literature presented related questions as open, including whether every FσδF_{\sigma\delta} ideal is Farah and whether every weakly Farah ideal is Farah.

Known results

  • Uniformly weak Ramsey ideals admit Borel I\mathcal{I}-maximal eventually different families; this includes arbitrary FσF_\sigma ideals and iterated Fubini products finα\mathrm{fin}^{\alpha} for α<ω1\alpha<\omega_1.
  • For ideals containing fin\mathrm{fin}, a Borel I\mathcal{I}-maximal eventually different family yields a closed one.

October 20, 2026 claimed resolution

A preprint by Jialiang He, Jiaheng Zhuang, and Yi Zhou claims an equivalence between the two ideal classes, establishes uniform weak Ramsey properties, and derives closed maximal eventually-different families for broad classes. If correct, this answers the tracked structural question; the claim remains unverified.

Current status (as of October 2026): The preprint claims the structural question is settled, but its equivalence theorem has not been independently verified; the result is therefore recorded as an unverified claimed solution.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.