← All problems

Strong geography restriction for rational homology spheres

For every rational homology 33-sphere YY, let the nonzero UU-torsion summands of HF−(Y)HF^-(Y), viewed as an F[U]\mathbb{F}[U]-module, have lengths ell1≥ell2≥⋯ell_1\geq ell_2\geq\cdots, where a summand of length elliell_i is isomorphic to F[U]/(Uelli)\mathbb{F}[U]/(U^{ell_i}). If at least two such summands occur, then ell1−ell2≤1ell_1-ell_2\leq 1.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A 2026 preprint claims an infinite family of counterexamples, but the disproof has not been independently checked.

The problem asks whether every rational homology sphere satisfies the strong Heegaard Floer geography restriction formulated in the 2024 paper by Isakova, Lidman, and Zemke. That paper left the question open while proving it for important surgery classes.

Known results

  • Knot surgeries, including nontrivial rational surgeries, satisfy the restriction (Isakova, Lidman, and Zemke, 2024).
  • Sufficiently large surgeries on links in S3S^3 satisfy it (Isakova, Lidman, and Zemke, 2024).
  • The result extends to nullhomologous knots and links in any LL-space (Isakova, Lidman, and Zemke, 2024).
  • Rustamov’s examples Σ(2,2n+1,4n+3)\Sigma(2,2n+1,4n+3), n≥3n\ge 3, are not large surgeries on links in S3S^3; this is not a counterexample to the geography restriction.

October 2026 claimed counterexample

On October 20, 2026, a report described Yuhui Chen and Shunyu Wan’s preprint as constructing an infinite family of explicit integer homology spheres violating the strong restriction and lying outside several surgery descriptions. This would disprove the conjecture, but the retrieved evidence contains no independent mathematical verification.

Current status (as of October 2026): The restriction is proved for several surgery classes, while Chen and Wan claim an infinite-family disproof for general rational homology spheres; that claim remains unverified.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.