Burago–Kleiner cut-and-project lattice-equivalence question
Let . Given a cut-and-project scheme with lattice , physical projection injective on , and internal projection dense in , let be a compact window satisfying and having boundary of Lebesgue measure zero. Is the associated regular cut-and-project set bi-Lipschitz equivalent to a lattice in ? That is, does there always exist a lattice and a bijection with constants such that for all ?
References
- A cut-and-project set which is not bi-Lipschitz equivalent to a lattice — arXiv — Alan Haynes
Source: arXiv
Progress summary
A new unrefereed preprint claims that a natural boundary condition does not guarantee that a cut-and-project set behaves like a lattice.
Burago and Kleiner asked whether every regular cut-and-project set is bi-Lipschitz equivalent to a lattice. The latest preprint claims a counterexample, which would settle the universal question negatively.
Known results
- Burago and Kleiner (1997) constructed separated nets in not bi-Lipschitz equivalent to .
- Burago and Kleiner proved an almost-everywhere positive result for regular cut-and-project sets in dimension .
- Haynes, Kelly, and Weiss extended the almost-everywhere result to -regular sets in arbitrary dimension.
- A 2024 paper established another full-measure class satisfying bi-Lipschitz equivalence, without resolving the universal question.
October 2026 counterexample
Alan Haynes’s preprint claims a cut-and-project set whose window has boundary measure zero, and which has uniform density, is nevertheless not bi-Lipschitz equivalent to any lattice. This would refute the proposed criterion, but the claim is unrefereed and no independent assessment was found.
Current status (as of October 2026): A preprint claims the universal statement is false, while the counterexample remains unverified.
Sources
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.