Bagaria–Goldberg tightly C^(n)-compact cardinal question
.
References
- Identity crisis on tightly C^(2)-compact cardinals — arXiv — Fengju Zhang
Source: arXiv
Progress summary
A new unrefereed paper claims the proposed implication fails at level two, while the broader question remains open.
Bagaria and Goldberg ask whether every tightly -compact cardinal belongs to . The latest material claims a negative answer for , but does not settle arbitrary .
Known results
- Under the Ultrapower Axiom, the implication holds for (Bagaria–Goldberg, Reflecting Measures).
- For , tight -compactness is characterized as being -extendible or a measurable limit of such cardinals (Bagaria–Goldberg).
- Usuba showed a consistency result refuting the first-level implication, from tight -compactness to membership.
October 2026 claimed negative answer for
Fengju Zhang’s preprint Identity crisis on tightly -compact cardinals claims that the implication fails at . This is an unrefereed claim and is not independently verified in the retrieved material.
Current status (as of October 2026): The counterexample is claimed but unverified; the implication for arbitrary remains open, with a conditional positive result under the Ultrapower Axiom.
Sources
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.