← All problems

Bagaria–Goldberg tightly C^(n)-compact cardinal question

∀n∈N (n≥1⇒∀κ [(κ is tightly C(n)-compact)⇒κ∈C(n+1)])\forall n\in\mathbb{N}\,(n\ge 1\Rightarrow \forall\kappa\,[(\kappa\text{ is tightly }\mathsf{C}^{(n)}\text{-compact})\Rightarrow \kappa\in\mathsf{C}^{(n+1)}]).

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A new unrefereed paper claims the proposed implication fails at level two, while the broader question remains open.

Bagaria and Goldberg ask whether every tightly C(n)\mathsf{C}^{(n)}-compact cardinal belongs to C(n+1)\mathsf{C}^{(n+1)}. The latest material claims a negative answer for n=2n=2, but does not settle arbitrary nn.

Known results

  • Under the Ultrapower Axiom, the implication holds for n≥2n\ge 2 (Bagaria–Goldberg, Reflecting Measures).
  • For n≥2n\ge 2, tight C(n)\mathsf{C}^{(n)}-compactness is characterized as being C(n−1)\mathsf{C}^{(n-1)}-extendible or a measurable limit of such cardinals (Bagaria–Goldberg).
  • Usuba showed a consistency result refuting the first-level implication, from tight C(1)\mathsf{C}^{(1)}-compactness to C(2)\mathsf{C}^{(2)} membership.

October 2026 claimed negative answer for n=2n=2

Fengju Zhang’s preprint Identity crisis on tightly C(2)\mathsf{C}^{(2)}-compact cardinals claims that the implication fails at n=2n=2. This is an unrefereed claim and is not independently verified in the retrieved material.

Current status (as of October 2026): The n=2n=2 counterexample is claimed but unverified; the implication for arbitrary nn remains open, with a conditional positive result under the Ultrapower Axiom.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.