Steinerberger’s finite-range frequency-function conjecture
For a bounded real-valued function for which the supremum below is attained, define for , , and . Steinerberger's conjecture asks whether being finite implies that is a single sinusoidal function, namely whether there exist constants such that for all .
References
- On the frequency function of periodic quasianalytic and non-quasianalytic functions — arXiv — Carlos Garzón, José Madrid
Source: arXiv
Progress summary
A new preprint claims the conjecture is false in general, while proving a narrower version for especially regular periodic functions, but neither claim has been independently checked.
Steinerberger’s conjecture says that a bounded real-valued function whose frequency function takes only finitely many values must be a sine-type function. A 2014 paper established related rigidity results but explicitly left this broader statement open.
Known results
- Periodic with and a fixed critical averaging radius is sine-type (Steinerberger, 2014).
- Under the same regularity, at most two possible maximal-interval radii also force (Steinerberger, 2014).
- The finite-range statement for bounded was explicitly left open (Steinerberger, 2014).
October 2026 preprint
Carlos Garzón and José Madrid claim a counterexample outside quasianalytic classes, thereby refuting the general characterization, and claim the characterization under a stronger quasianalytic hypothesis for periodic functions. The preprint is unrefereed and has no independent confirmation in the retrieved material.
Current status (as of October 2026): The general conjecture is claimed false, and the stronger quasianalytic periodic case is claimed proved, but both claims remain unverified.
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.