← All problems

Minty equivalence problem in CAT(0) spaces

Let XX be a CAT(0)\mathrm{CAT}(0) space and let AA be a monotone operator formulated via the tangential approach on the tangent bundle TXTX. Is AA maximal monotone if and only if its resolvent has full domain, that is, if and only if dom⁡JA=X\operatorname{dom}J_A=X?

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A new unrefereed paper rules out some proposed extensions, proves special positive cases, and leaves the general question open.

The problem asks when Minty’s equivalence between monotone maximality and a surjectivity condition extends from linear spaces to CAT(0)\mathrm{CAT}(0) spaces. It compares dual-space, linear-dual, and tangential formulations.

Known results

  • Negative results for dual-space and linear-dual formulations.
  • Positive results for R\mathbb{R}-trees.
  • Positive results for certain Hilbert–Hadamard spaces.
  • The general tangential formulation remains open.

October 2026 partial results

On October 18, 2026, Parin Chaipunya’s preprint reported the negative and positive cases above, separating several competing formulations rather than resolving the general problem. The tangential formulation remains open, and the preprint is unrefereed.

Current status (as of October 2026): Special cases and obstructions are reported, but the general tangential Minty equivalence in CAT(0)\mathrm{CAT}(0) spaces remains open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.