← All problems

Karpukhin Steklov conjectures and Open Questions 7.19, 7.23, and 7.27

Let Mn+1M^{n+1} be a smooth compact connected oriented Riemannian manifold with boundary, and let TpT_p be Karpukhin’s Dirichlet-to-Neumann operator on differential pp-forms, with eigenvalue counting function Np(τ)N_p(\tau). The problem consists of the following assertions: (1) determine whether TpT_p, for 0≤p≤n−20\leq p\leq n-2, is a classical elliptic pseudodifferential operator of order one on the coclosed symbol space and determine its principal symbol; (2) in the smooth case, establish the Weyl asymptotic with remainder Np(τ)=Cn,pVol⁡(∂M)τn+O(τn−2)N_p(\tau)=C_{n,p}\operatorname{Vol}(\partial M)\tau^n+O(\tau^{n-2}); (3) in the critical dimension n=2p+2n=2p+2, determine whether equality throughout Karpukhin’s initial equality range forces (M,g)(M,g) to be isometric to a Euclidean ball; and (4) determine whether Karpukhin’s eigenvalue bounds are sharp for every index and form degree, in particular whether for every p≥1p\geq 1 and every index kk there are smooth compact connected oriented manifolds with boundary attaining the conjectured sharp asymptotic scale.

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

An October 2026 preprint claims to settle three long-standing questions about Steklov operators on differential forms, but the claims have not been independently checked.

Karpukhin formulated conjectures concerning rigidity in the equality case and sharpness of eigenvalue bounds for Steklov operators on differential forms. The tracked entry concerns three related structural and asymptotic questions.

Known results

  • Karpukhin, 2017: formulated the rigidity conjecture that equality below the stated threshold forces the manifold to be a Euclidean ball.
  • Karpukhin, 2017: conjectured sharpness for every index and form degree via manifolds assembled from equal-radius Euclidean balls.
  • Raulot and Savo, 2021: established an analogous eigenvalue estimate and Weyl law for Karpukhin’s operator, without resolving the three tracked questions.

October 2026 preprint

Daguang Chen, Guotao Huang, and Tingyu Liao claim a Weyl-law remainder, a counterexample to critical-dimensional isometry rigidity, and an all-index sharpness theorem. These assertions would settle the tracked questions, but the preprint is unrefereed and no independent mathematical assessment was retrieved.

Current status (as of October 2026): The preprint claims to settle the tracked questions, but its results remain unverified; earlier partial results do not settle them independently.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.