← All problems

Kusner’s Willmore-minimizer conjecture and related Veronese uniqueness conjectures

Among all immersed copies f:RP2→S4f:\mathbb{RP}^{2}\to\mathbb{S}^{4}, every immersion minimizing the Willmore energy is, up to reparametrization and a conformal transformation of S4\mathbb{S}^{4}, the Veronese immersion.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A new preprint claims progress on existence of certain Willmore minimizers, but it does not identify them as Veronese surfaces or prove uniqueness, so the main conjectures remain open.

Kusner’s conjecture predicts specific Lawson surfaces minimize Willmore energy in higher genus, while related questions ask whether Veronese surfaces are the unique minimizers in the relevant classes. The general higher-genus minimization and Veronese uniqueness statements remain unresolved.

Known results

  • Marques and Neves, 2014: the genus-one Willmore conjecture was proved, with equality only for the Clifford torus.
  • Bauer and Kuwert: existence of a smooth minimizer for each fixed genus.
  • Kusner, Lü, and Wang, 2024: the Lawson minimization conjecture was proved only under shared ambient symmetries; the unrestricted case remains open.
  • Li and Yau: every immersed projective plane in four-dimensional Euclidean space has Willmore energy at least 6π6\pi, with equality for the Veronese surface.

October 2026 index-minimizer result

A preprint by Jacob Bernstein and Daniel Ketover claims existence, for every n≥4n\geq 4, of an index-(n+1)(n+1) minimizer in the stated class, plus a nonzero-Euler-number result in S4S^4. This is claimed progress, not a solution: the minimizer is not identified with the Veronese embedding, and uniqueness is not proved.

Current status (as of October 2026): the recent existence and index result is unverified, while the Veronese identification, uniqueness claims, and unrestricted higher-genus Lawson minimization conjecture remain open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.