← All problems

Fraser’s Questions 17.8.1 and 17.8.2

For integers 1≤k<d1\le k<d and every bounded set F⊂RdF\subset\mathbb{R}^d, define Ek(F)={V∈Gr⁡(d,k):dim⁡A(πV(F))<min⁡{k,dim⁡AF}}E_k(F)=\{V\in\operatorname{Gr}(d,k):\dim_{\mathrm A}(\pi_V(F))<\min\{k,\dim_{\mathrm A}F\}\}, where Gr⁡(d,k)\operatorname{Gr}(d,k) is the Grassmannian of kk-dimensional linear subspaces and πV\pi_V is orthogonal projection onto VV. Fraser's Question 17.8.1 asks whether dim⁡HEk(F)≤k(d−1−k)\dim_{\mathrm H}E_k(F)\le k(d-1-k) for all such FF.

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A new preprint claims a counterexample to the proposed bound in a restricted class, while the general questions remain open.

Fraser’s Questions 17.8.1 and 17.8.2 concern a proposed universal bound for exceptional projections onto kk-planes. The reported advance addresses a restricted class of sets rather than the full problem.

October 2026 claimed counterexample

Bilel Selmi’s preprint claims explicit Hausdorff and packing dimensions for exceptional kk-planes when the set contains a relatively open subset of a lower-dimensional subspace, and claims that the proposed bound fails there. This is claimed progress, not a complete resolution: the optimal bound for arbitrary higher-dimensional sets remains undetermined.

Current status (as of October 2026): Selmi’s preprint claims a counterexample in a specified model class, while the questions for arbitrary higher-dimensional sets remain open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.