← All problems

Brettell–Jowett–Oxley–Semple–Whittle tangle-minor conjectures

For integers kk and ll, every matroid having a tangle of order kk and breadth ll has a minor that has a tangle of order kk and breadth ll and is weakly 44-connected. A stronger proposed version requires the minor to be internally 44-connected instead.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A 2026 preprint claims counterexamples to both structural rules, but this conflicts with a 2025 proof of the weak version and has not been independently checked.

The conjectures concern whether a matroid with a tangle of order kk and breadth ll has a minor retaining those parameters that is weakly 44-connected, or internally 44-connected. The associated work is by Nick Brettell, Susan Jowett, James Oxley, Charles Semple, and Geoff Whittle.

Known results

  • Brettell, Jowett, Oxley, Semple, and Whittle, version dated March 4, 2025: proved the weakly 44-connected reduction for k≥4k\ge 4, preserving tangle breadth ll.
  • The same paper proved the corresponding set-theoretic consequence for n≥3k−5n\ge 3k-5; for k=4k=4, this gives n≥7n\ge 7.
  • Its examples show that weakly 44-connected cannot generally be strengthened to internally 44-connected while preserving breadth, even for graphic matroids.

October 2026 claimed counterexamples

An October 2026 preprint claims explicit matroids showing that the required weakly 44-connected or internally 44-connected minors need not exist while preserving tangle breadth. This would contradict the retrieved weakly 44-connected theorem as well as settle the proposed obstructions, but the preprint is unrefereed and no independent mathematical assessment was retrieved.

Current status (as of October 2026): the weakly 44-connected principle is proved in the 2025 paper and the internally 44-connected strengthening is obstructed there, while the newer claim of counterexamples to both principles remains unverified.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.