← All problems

Wahl’s Main Conjecture on defects of non-Gorenstein surface singularities

Let (V,0)(V,0) be a non-Gorenstein normal complex surface singularity other than a rational double point, and let (X,E)→(V,0)(X,E)\to(V,0) be its minimal good resolution, with EE reduced. Set SX=ΘX(−log⁡E)S_X=\Theta_X(-\log E) and Δ(V,0)=h1(OX)−h1(SX)+h1(⋀2SX)\Delta(V,0)=h^1(\mathcal{O}_X)-h^1(S_X)+h^1(\bigwedge^2 S_X). Then Δ(V,0)≥0\Delta(V,0)\ge 0, with equality if and only if (V,0)(V,0) is quasi-homogeneous.

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

An unrefereed preprint claims the conjecture is false and constructs examples with defects arbitrarily far below zero.

Wahl’s Main Conjecture proposed universal nonnegativity for defects of non-Gorenstein surface singularities. The reported construction instead gives hyperelliptic nonlinear neighborhoods realizing every nonpositive integer as a defect.

October 15, 2026 counterexamples

Heesang Park and Dongsoo Shin report in the preprint Nonlinear neighborhoods of smooth curves and arbitrarily negative Wahl defects that hyperelliptic nonlinear neighborhoods attain every nonpositive integer and the genus-dependent lower bound. If correct, this disproves the conjecture and explains arbitrarily negative defects; the result remains unverified because the retrieved evidence is an unrefereed preprint.

Current status (as of October 2026): The conjecture is claimed disproved by explicit constructions, but the reported counterexamples have not been independently verified; no narrower surviving formulation is established in the retrieved evidence.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.