← All problems

Plotnick’s conjecture on knot exteriors

For four-dimensional knot exteriors, homotopy equivalence is conjectured to force topological equivalence: for any two 22-knots K1,K2⊂S4K_1,K_2\subset S^4, if their exteriors XKi=S4∖ν(Ki)‾X_{K_i}=\overline{S^4\setminus \nu(K_i)} are homotopy equivalent, then XK1X_{K_1} and XK2X_{K_2} are homeomorphic (equivalently, no pair of non-homeomorphic 22-knot exteriors can be homotopy equivalent).

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A 2026 preprint claims to disprove the conjecture with an explicit counterexample, but the claim has not been independently checked.

Plotnick’s conjecture concerns whether certain four-dimensional knot exteriors can share homotopy-type invariants while remaining topologically distinguishable. Tommy Hofmann and John Nicholson claim that an explicit group-ring construction produces a counterexample.

October 2026 counterexample

Hofmann and Nicholson use an augmentation-4949 group-ring unit to establish the required simple-homotopy equivalence and claim that this disproves Plotnick’s conjecture. The retrieved preprint is the only substantive source located, so the counterexample remains unverified here.

Current status (as of October 2026): Plotnick’s conjecture is claimed to be disproved by Hofmann and Nicholson’s explicit counterexample, but the result has not been independently verified.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.