← All problems

Canary–Taylor and Canary–Minsky–Taylor questions on round limit sets and Hausdorff dimension

Let MM be a sufficiently appropriate compact hyperbolic 33-orbifold with totally geodesic boundary, and let XFX_F be a complete convex cocompact hyperbolic structure on int⁡(M)\operatorname{int}(M) with Fuchsian ends. Is XFX_F a global minimizer of the Hausdorff dimension of the limit set among all complete convex cocompact structures XX on int⁡(M)\operatorname{int}(M); that is, does dim⁡HΛ(XF)≤dim⁡HΛ(X)\dim_H\Lambda(X_F)\leq \dim_H\Lambda(X) hold for every such XX?

Equivalent formulations
  1. Among the complete convex cocompact hyperbolic structures on int⁡(M)\operatorname{int}(M), do structures whose limit sets are round minimize the Hausdorff dimension of the limit set?

    source: Douba, Sambarino, and Pallete, “On local minimality of Hausdorff dimension for round limit sets”

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A new paper proves the expected minimum property in several highly symmetric examples, but the general questions remain open.

The Canary–Taylor and Canary–Minsky–Taylor questions ask whether round limit sets, equivalently structures with Fuchsian ends in the relevant setting, minimize Hausdorff dimension. The new work establishes only local and symmetry-dependent cases, not the general conjectural principle.

Known results

  • Minsky and Taylor (1999) related the infimum D(M)D(M) of limit-set dimensions to the supremum Λ(M)\Lambda(M) of the bottom of the L2L^2 spectrum via Λ(M)=D(M)(2−D(M))\Lambda(M)=D(M)(2-D(M)) in the stated non-exceptional cases.
  • Minsky and Taylor (1999) characterized the case D(M)=1D(M)=1 for the relevant compact 33-manifolds and recorded D(M)=0D(M)=0 for handlebodies and thickened tori.

October 14, 2026 local-minimality results

On October 14, 2026, Sami Douba, Andrés Sambarino, and Franco Vargas Pallete reported that, for sufficiently symmetric compact hyperbolic 33-orbifolds with totally geodesic boundary, the Fuchsian-ended structure is a critical point and, under stronger symmetry, a strict local minimum of the critical exponent among complete convex cocompact structures. They also give infinitely many non-rigid examples. This is a claimed advance, not a general resolution.

Current status (as of October 2026): The cited local-minimality cases and non-rigid examples are reported, while the general Canary–Taylor and Canary–Minsky–Taylor minimization questions remain open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.