← All problems

Sobriety problem for locally compact dcpos

Determine whether every dcpo PP whose Scott topology σ(P)\sigma(P) is locally compact is sober; equivalently, whether every nonempty irreducible closed subset C⊆PC\subseteq P is of the form C={x}‾σ(P)C=\overline{\{x\}}^{\sigma(P)} for a unique point x∈Px\in P.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A new unrefereed preprint proves sobriety for two broad subclasses, but the general question remains open.

The problem asks whether every locally compact dcpo is sober in its Scott topology. Zhengmao He and Yujing Zhang’s October 2026 preprint records substantial positive results without settling the unrestricted question.

Known results

  • A locally compact sup-semilattice with sober Scott-space behavior under the stated hypotheses is sober (2022 source).
  • Countable dcpos with core-compact Scott spaces are sober (2026 source).
  • Some meet-continuous LL-dcpos are sober under product-topology hypotheses; these conditions imply sobriety and local compactness in the relevant cases (2026 source).
  • The lattice of open sets of Q\mathbb{Q} supplies a non-sober Scott space, but it is not a counterexample under the target locally compact hypothesis (2026 source).

October 13, 2026 sufficient conditions

On October 13, 2026, He and Zhang’s preprint The sobriety for locally compact dcpos proved sobriety for every meet-continuous, locally compact, coherent dcpo and for every locally compact, second-countable dcpo. These are claimed advances, but the preprint is unrefereed and does not resolve the general problem.

Current status (as of October 2026): The general locally compact-dcpo sobriety problem remains open; sobriety is established only for several substantial subclasses.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.