← All problems

Henle–Mathias–Woodin question on consecutive measurable cardinals

Con⁡ ⁣(ZF+∃⟨κn:n<ω⟩ [∀n<ω (κn is measurable ∧ κn+1=κn+)]) \operatorname{Con}\!\left(\mathrm{ZF}+\exists\langle\kappa_n:n<\omega\rangle\,\left[\forall n<\omega\,\bigl(\kappa_n\text{ is measurable}\ \wedge\ \kappa_{n+1}=\kappa_n^+\bigr)\right]\right): is it consistent with ZF \mathrm{ZF} that there are infinitely many consecutive measurable cardinals? Here κn+ \kappa_n^+ denotes the successor cardinal of κn \kappa_n.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A new preprint claims to answer the question by constructing models with infinitely many adjacent measurable cardinals, but the claim has not been independently verified.

The Henle–Mathias–Woodin question concerns whether particular large-cardinal patterns can occur consecutively in models without the full axiom of choice. The retrieved material supplies no earlier attribution or date for the question.

October 2026 preprint

Gabriel Goldberg and Grigor Sargsyan's Measures in Nairian models, I reports a consistency construction with infinitely many consecutive measurable cardinals, together with a related model in which every uncountable cardinal is singular. If correct, this answers the named question under the paper's stated large-cardinal and determinacy assumptions; it remains an unverified preprint claim.

Current status (as of October 2026): The preprint claims a conditional resolution, but no independent verification is recorded, so the result is not yet settled.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.