Ball’s weak cylinder conjecture
For every prime , let satisfy . A direction is called non-determined by if every affine line of that direction contains at most one point of . If has at least non-determined directions, then is a union of mutually parallel affine lines.
References
- The weak cylinder conjecture for polynomial graphs of bounded degree — arXiv — Daniele Bartoli, Alessandro Giannoni
Source: arXiv
Progress summary
A new result proves the conjecture for a substantial class of algebraic examples, but the general case is open.
Ball’s weak cylinder conjecture asserts that a set of points in with at least nondetermined directions must be a cylinder. The full statement for arbitrary sets remains unresolved.
Known results
- Computational verification covers the strong conjecture for ; the weak conjecture is reported open for . A counterexample over does not apply to the prime-field version.
October 2026 bounded-degree advance
Bartoli and Giannoni claim the conjecture for polynomial graphs of degree at most when , and for for every odd prime. For actual degree , they prove for noncylindrical graphs. The paper explicitly leaves the arbitrary-set conjecture open.
Current status (as of October 2026): The conjecture is claimed for the reported bounded-degree polynomial-graph class, while the full arbitrary-set case remains open.
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.