← All problems

Ball’s weak cylinder conjecture

For every prime pp, let S⊆AG(3,p)=Fp3S\subseteq\mathrm{AG}(3,p)=\mathbb{F}_p^3 satisfy ∣S∣=p2|S|=p^2. A direction is called non-determined by SS if every affine line of that direction contains at most one point of SS. If SS has at least pp non-determined directions, then SS is a union of pp mutually parallel affine lines.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A new result proves the conjecture for a substantial class of algebraic examples, but the general case is open.

Ball’s weak cylinder conjecture asserts that a set of p2p^2 points in Fp3\mathbb{F}_p^3 with at least pp nondetermined directions must be a cylinder. The full statement for arbitrary sets remains unresolved.

Known results

  • Computational verification covers the strong conjecture for p≤7p\le 7; the weak conjecture is reported open for p>7p>7. A counterexample over F8\mathbb{F}_8 does not apply to the prime-field version.

October 2026 bounded-degree advance

Bartoli and Giannoni claim the conjecture for polynomial graphs of degree at most DD when p>D9/2p>D^{9/2}, and for D≤2D\le 2 for every odd prime. For actual degree D≥3D\ge 3, they prove ∣NS∣≤p+1−⌈p/(D−1)⌉|\mathcal{N}_S|\le p+1-\lceil p/(D-1)\rceil for noncylindrical graphs. The paper explicitly leaves the arbitrary-set conjecture open.

Current status (as of October 2026): The conjecture is claimed for the reported bounded-degree polynomial-graph class, while the full arbitrary-set case remains open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.