← All problems

Naor–Sheffield absolutely minimizing Lipschitz extension question

Let HH and KK be real Hilbert spaces, let A⊆HA\subseteq H be closed, and let f:A→Kf:A\to K be Lipschitz. Does there exist a Lipschitz extension F:H→KF:H\to K with F∣A=fF|_A=f such that, for every nonempty open set U⊆H∖AU\subseteq H\setminus A, Lip⁡(F∣U)=Lip⁡(F∣∂U)\operatorname{Lip}(F|_U)=\operatorname{Lip}(F|_{\partial U})?

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A new unrefereed paper claims the long-standing extension problem has a complete affirmative solution in every Hilbert space, but the claim has not been independently checked.

The Naor–Sheffield question asks whether suitable absolutely minimizing extensions always exist for Lipschitz maps between Hilbert spaces. The affirmative claim also removes separability assumptions and adds density, uniqueness, and operator-characterization results.

Known results

  • Kirszbraun (1934): arbitrary Hilbert spaces have the isometric Lipschitz extension property.
  • Naor–Sheffield (2012): studied vector-valued absolutely minimizing extensions, showing that uniqueness can fail and introducing stronger tightness conditions.
  • Naor–Sheffield: established unique absolutely minimizing extensions for maps into metric trees from closed subsets of locally compact length spaces.

October 12, 2026 claimed solution

Krzysztof J. Ciosmak’s preprint Absolutely minimising Lipschitz extensions between Hilbert spaces claims that every Lipschitz map from a closed subset of a real Hilbert space to a real Hilbert space has an absolutely minimizing extension, without separability assumptions. It further claims results for targets of dimension at least 22. The preprint is unrefereed, and no independent verification or substantive assessment was found.

Current status (as of October 2026): The general existence question is claimed solved by Ciosmak’s preprint, but that claim remains unverified; the earlier partial results are established.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.