← All problems

Geelen–Nelson–Walsh, Averkov–Schymura, and Basit–Dvir–Saraf–Wolf questions

For every integer n≥1n\ge 1 and every set P⊂C3P\subset\mathbb{C}^3 of nn points such that every affine plane Π⊂C3\Pi\subset\mathbb{C}^3 satisfies ∣P∩Π∣≤2n/3|P\cap\Pi|\le 2n/3, does PP determine at least cn2cn^2 ordinary lines for some absolute constant c>0c>0? Here an ordinary line is an affine line ℓ\ell satisfying ∣ℓ∩P∣=2|\ell\cap P|=2. Kroeker and Lund claim the stronger bound that there are at least n2/40n^2/40 ordinary lines.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · progress reported

A new preprint claims substantial progress on three related questions, but its question-resolving consequences have not been independently verified.

The entry concerns questions connecting ordinary lines in complex space, density bounds for complex-representable matroids, and related incidence estimates. No proposer or original date is identified in the retrieved sources.

Known results

  • Geelen–Nelson–Walsh established the sharp large-rank bound ∣M∣≤(ℓ−1)(r2)+r|M|\le (\ell-1)\binom{r}{2}+r for simple rank-rr C\mathbb{C}-representable matroids excluding a U2,ℓ+2U_{2,\ell+2}-minor, with equality characterized by cyclic Dowling geometries.
  • Basit–Dvir–Saraf–Wolf proved that nn points spanning C3\mathbb{C}^3 determine at least 3n/23n/2 ordinary lines, apart from the stated planar exceptional configuration.
  • Their higher-dimensional theorem gives a quadratic ordinary-line bound under a non-concentration hypothesis.
  • A real R3\mathbb{R}^3 analogue gives cαn2c_\alpha n^2 ordinary lines for every α<1\alpha<1, while optimal constants remain open.

October 2026 preprint

Kroeker and Lund claim a rank-independent matroid estimate, namely at most 14d4l\frac14 d^4l elements for d≥3d\ge 3, via an improved Sylvester–Gallai-type bound, and claim the cited ordinary-line lower bound in C3\mathbb{C}^3. The source presents these as preprint results; no independent verification was found.

Current status (as of October 2026): The earlier rank-asymptotic matroid theorem and existing ordinary-line results are established, while the new rank-independent and C3\mathbb{C}^3 question-resolving claims remain unverified.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.