Smale’s mean value conjecture/question
Let be the class of complex polynomials of degree at least satisfying and . Define and . Smale's mean value conjecture asks whether ; equivalently, whether every has a critical point such that .
Equivalent formulations
Let , where the supremum is over pairs such that is a normalized univalent map of the unit disk , is a finite Blaschke product with , and is locally univalent in . The conjecture is equivalent, via , to the assertion .
source: Smale's mean value constant and admissible univalent Blaschke pairs
References
- Smale's mean value constant and admissible univalent Blaschke pairs — arXiv — Aneesh Jatar, Tuen Wai Ng
Source: arXiv
Progress summary
A new October 2026 preprint improves the known lower bound, but the exact constant remains unknown.
Smale’s 1981 question asks whether every complex polynomial has a critical point satisfying the normalized bound . The unrestricted conjecture remains unsettled.
Known results
- Smale established the weaker bound (1981).
- Tischler (1989) proved the conjectured bound for several structured root configurations.
- The conjectured value is known for degrees , and degree is attributed to Sendov and Marinov.
- Conte et al. (2007) obtained ; Crane (2007) obtained .
October 2026 lower-bound advance
Aneesh Jatar and Tuen Wai Ng report and transfer the lower bound to arbitrarily large degrees. This rules out under their argument, but the preprint does not determine the exact constant.
Current status (as of October 2026): The exact Smale constant remains open; a new preprint claims a stronger lower bound and excludes , without settling the conjecture.
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.