← All problems

Howie’s conjecture on Brodskiĭ’s quasivariety

Let B\mathcal{B} denote Brodskiĭ’s quasivariety and let L\mathcal{L} denote the quasivariety of locally indicable groups. The conjecture asserts that B=L\mathcal{B}=\mathcal{L}; equivalently, every locally indicable group belongs to Brodskiĭ’s quasivariety. Here a group GG is locally indicable if every nontrivial finitely generated subgroup H≤GH\leq G admits a surjective homomorphism H↠ZH\twoheadrightarrow\mathbb{Z}.

Equivalent formulations
  1. Every locally indicable group belongs to Brodskiĭ’s quasivariety.

    source: Locally indicable groups outside Brodskiĭ’s quasivariety

References

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A 2026 preprint claims a counterexample, but no independent check has established that the conjecture is false.

Howie’s conjecture asks whether Brodskiĭ’s quasivariety coincides with the quasivariety of locally indicable groups. The retrieved sources associate the question with Howie but do not provide a fuller history or definitive resolution.

Known results

  • Howie proved the Kervaire–Laudenbach conjecture for locally indicable groups; related work also studied quasivarieties generated by finite and locally indicable groups, without resolving this question.

October 2026 claimed counterexample

Hannah Boß’s preprint claims that Brodskiĭ’s quasivariety does not contain every locally indicable group. It gives obstructions to membership and examples of locally indicable groups satisfying them; related material asserts a metabelian group with a unimodular equation w(x)=1w(x)=1 having no solution in any metabelian overgroup. The claimed counterexample remains unverified.

Current status (as of October 2026): The conjecture is not established as false; the proposed counterexample is unverified, so the question remains open.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.