← All problems

Smillie–Weiss question on completely parabolic surfaces

Let XX be a compact translation surface. Assume that XX is completely parabolic: every direction containing a saddle connection decomposes XX into finitely many cylinders whose moduli mod⁡(C)=height⁡(C)/circumference⁡(C)\operatorname{mod}(C)=\operatorname{height}(C)/\operatorname{circumference}(C) are pairwise commensurable. Must XX be a Veech surface, i.e. must its affine automorphism group have derivative group SL⁡(X)⊆SL⁡(2,R)\operatorname{SL}(X)\subseteq \operatorname{SL}(2,\mathbb{R}) that is a lattice?

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A new paper claims that the dynamical condition in the question always forces the strong affine symmetry defining a Veech surface, but the claim has not been independently checked.

The Smillie–Weiss question asks whether complete parabolicity of a translation surface implies that it is Veech. The retrieved literature identifies this as the question, while earlier work settled stronger or restricted versions.

Known results

  • Uniform complete parabolicity implies the Veech/lattice property (Smillie–Weiss, 2008).
  • Complete parabolicity implies the Veech property for surfaces in rank-11 orbit closures (2015 paper).
  • The implication was also claimed there in genus 22 and in Prym loci; the general case was not established in that source.

October 2026 claimed resolution

In October 2026, Inbo Gottlieb Fenves’s paper Completely parabolic surfaces are Veech claimed the full implication for translation surfaces. This would settle the Smillie–Weiss question, but the retrieved record contains no independent mathematical assessment, verification, error analysis, or withdrawal.

Current status (as of October 2026): The full implication is claimed by Fenves but remains unverified; the uniform, rank-11, genus-22, and Prym cases are the established partial results in the retrieved sources.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.