Min-Oo’s conjecture
For every integer , let be a smooth compact connected oriented Riemannian manifold with boundary. If the scalar curvature satisfies , the boundary is isometric to the standard unit -sphere, and the outward boundary mean curvature satisfies , then is isometric to the standard unit hemisphere , with boundary the equatorial sphere.
References
- Scalar curvature rigidity of small spherical caps with arbitrary fill-ins — arXiv — Yiyue Zhang, Bowen Zhao
Status
- Refuted: Simon Brendle, Fernando C. Marques, and André Neves. Deformations of the hemisphere that increase scalar curvature (Journal of Differential Geometry 88 (2011), no. 1, 2011) https://arxiv.org/abs/1004.3088
Source: arXiv
Progress summary
The original conjecture was disproved, but a new result recovers rigidity for sufficiently small caps; the full statement remains false.
Min-Oo proposed the conjecture in 1995: scalar-curvature and boundary conditions should force a manifold to be the standard hemisphere. Brendle, Marques, and Neves disproved it in every dimension at least three.
Known results
- Brendle, Marques, and Neves constructed counterexamples for every .
- Brendle and Marques proved local rigidity for suitable spherical caps, though not for the hemisphere.
- Brendle, Marques, and Neves recovered rigidity under an additional volume constraint.
- Sweeney, 2025, constructed further non-perturbative counterexamples with standard totally geodesic boundary.
October 2026 localized rigidity
Yiyue Zhang and Bowen Zhao claim rigidity for spherical caps whose radii lie below a dimension-dependent threshold, in every dimension . This is a localized positive result only; it does not restore the false unrestricted conjecture, and the claim is unverified.
Current status (as of October 2026): The unrestricted conjecture is false for , while rigidity is claimed for sufficiently small caps; the exact boundary between the positive and negative regimes remains open.
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.