Generalized Nerves of Steel conjecture
For every essentially small tensor-triangulated category , the canonical comparison map from the homological spectrum to the Balmer spectrum, , is injective; equivalently, the homological and tensor-triangular spectra agree.
References
- Tensor triangular geometry of band algebras — arXiv — Peng Xu
Source: arXiv
Progress summary
Recent specialist preprints claim that the generalized conjecture is false, including in the rigid setting, but the claims have not been independently verified.
The conjecture concerns whether homological and tensor-triangular spectra agree, equivalently an exact-nilpotence property in local tensor-triangulated categories. Hyslop formulated the relevant generalized condition in 2024; later preprints claim counterexamples to both non-rigid and rigid versions.
Known results
- Hyslop (2024): the exact-nilpotence condition is equivalent to the Nerves of Steel conjecture, can fail non-rigidly, and holds for a broad class.
- Barthel, Hyslop, and Ramzi (2026): claimed failure of injectivity for a free rigid commutative -ring.
- Coulembier (2026): claimed another rigid counterexample, also refuting the generalized formulation.
October 2026 band-algebra counterexample
Peng Xu’s paper identifies spectra and localizing ideals for band algebras and exhibits a counterexample outside the rigid setting. This supports the stated non-rigid limitation, while the 2026 rigid counterexamples claim that even the rigid formulation fails; these preprint claims remain unverified.
Current status (as of October 2026): The generalized conjecture is claimed false through non-rigid and rigid counterexamples, but no independent verification is recorded.
Solutions 0
No solutions have been posted yet.