← All problems

Mueller–Ho conjecture

For s>0s>0, z=x+iy∈H={x+iy:y>0}z=x+iy\in\mathbb H=\{x+iy:y>0\}, define θ(s;z)=∑m,n∈Ze−πs(m2y+(mx−n)2y)\theta(s;z)=\sum_{m,n\in\mathbb Z}e^{-\pi s\left(m^2y+\frac{(mx-n)^2}{y}\right)} and J(z;a,b)=∑m,n∈Ze−π(m2y+(mx−n)2y)cos⁡(2π(ma+nb))J(z;a,b)=\sum_{m,n\in\mathbb Z}e^{-\pi\left(m^2y+\frac{(mx-n)^2}{y}\right)}\cos\bigl(2\pi(ma+nb)\bigr). The Mueller–Ho conjecture asserts that, up to the modular group, there exist constants 0<αa<αb<αc<10<\alpha_a<\alpha_b<\alpha_c<1 such that the minimizers of θ(1;z)+αJ(z;a,b)\theta(1;z)+\alpha J(z;a,b) over z∈Hz\in\mathbb H and (a,b)∈R2(a,b)\in\mathbb R^2 are classified as follows: for α∈[0,αa)\alpha\in[0,\alpha_a), the minimizer is (eiπ/3;1/3,1/3)\left(e^{i\pi/3};1/3,1/3\right); for α=αa\alpha=\alpha_a, the minimizers are (eiπ/3;1/3,1/3)\left(e^{i\pi/3};1/3,1/3\right) and (eiφαa;1/2,1/2)\left(e^{i\varphi_{\alpha_a}};1/2,1/2\right); for α∈(αa,αb)\alpha\in(\alpha_a,\alpha_b), the minimizer is (eiφα;1/2,1/2)\left(e^{i\varphi_\alpha};1/2,1/2\right) with φα∈(φαa,π/2)\varphi_\alpha\in(\varphi_{\alpha_a},\pi/2); for α∈[αb,αc]\alpha\in[\alpha_b,\alpha_c], the minimizer is (i;1/2,1/2)(i;1/2,1/2); and for α∈(αc,1]\alpha\in(\alpha_c,1], the minimizer is (iyα;1/2,1/2)(iy_\alpha;1/2,1/2) with yα∈(1,3]y_\alpha\in(1,\sqrt{3}] and y1=3y_1=\sqrt{3}.

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

A new preprint claims a complete classification, but independent confirmation is absent and the earlier literature proved only partial results.

The Mueller–Ho conjecture concerns minimization of theta-function energies governing lattice shapes and relative vortex positions in two-component Bose–Einstein condensates. Luo and Wei’s 2020 paper gave a partial answer, leaving a critical-points conjecture needed for a complete proof.

Known results

  • Luo and Wei, 2020: as ρ\rho varies, minimizers pass through rectangular, square, rhombic, and hexagonal lattice regimes, with a square-lattice interval.
  • For relative displacement (a,b)=(1/2,1/2)(a,b)=(1/2,1/2), the 2020 paper reported thresholds α1∼0.3732155067\alpha_1\sim0.3732155067 and α2∼0.9256496973\alpha_2\sim0.9256496973, but described the result as conditional on a critical-points conjecture.
  • Earlier work predicted triangular, rhombic, square, and rectangular phases across parameter ranges, without proving the full conjecture.

October 2026 claimed complete proof

In October 2026, Senping Luo and Juncheng Wei submitted A Complete Proof of Mueller--Ho Conjecture, claiming parameter thresholds, lattice shapes, and relative positions of minimizers. The retrieved record contains no independent substantive assessment, so this remains an unverified claim.

Current status (as of October 2026): The conjecture has a new claimed complete proof, but only the earlier partial results are independently documented here; the claimed resolution remains unverified.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.