← All problems

Iyama’s left-right symmetry question for diagonal Auslander-regularity

Let kk be a field and let AA be a finite-dimensional Auslander-regular kk-algebra. For a finitely generated right AA-module MM, write grade⁡AM=inf⁡{i≥0:Ext⁡Ai(M,A)≠0}\operatorname{grade}_A M=\inf\{i\ge 0:\operatorname{Ext}^i_A(M,A)\ne 0\}. If AA is right diagonal, meaning that pdim⁡AS=grade⁡AS\operatorname{pdim}_A S=\operatorname{grade}_A S for every simple right AA-module SS, must Aop⁡A^{\operatorname{op}} also be right diagonal? Equivalently, must pdim⁡AT=grade⁡AT\operatorname{pdim}_A T=\operatorname{grade}_A T hold for every simple left AA-module TT?

References

Source: arXiv

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

An unrefereed 2026 preprint claims a concrete example showing that the proposed left-right symmetry fails, but the claim has not been independently checked.

Iyama asked whether a finite-dimensional algebra that is diagonal Auslander-regular must have the same property for its opposite algebra. Zhenyu Wang, Zhaoyong Huang, and Yu-Zhe Liu claim a negative answer.

October 2026 counterexample

The claimed example is an acyclic quiver algebra AA over a characteristic-00 field with 99 simple modules and dimension 3131: AA is diagonal Auslander-regular, but Aop⁡A^{\operatorname{op}} is not. For a left simple module S(7)S(7), the authors report pdim⁡AS(7)=1\operatorname{pdim}_A S(7)=1, idim⁡AS(7)=2\operatorname{idim}_A S(7)=2, and grade⁡AS(7)=cograde⁡AS(7)=1\operatorname{grade}_A S(7)=\operatorname{cograde}_A S(7)=1, yielding the failure on the opposite side. The preprint says ChatGPT-5.6 Sol assisted with auxiliary work; the authors directed the mathematics.

Current status (as of October 2026): A counterexample is claimed to settle Iyama’s question negatively, but the result remains unverified in an unrefereed preprint.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.